A mother claims her son was unfairly criticized on his third-grade report card for sticking his tongue out at another student during recess, leading to a lawsuit against the Palo Alto Unified School District.
The comments on her son's report card were based on a game of tag at recess, when her son stuck his tongue out another student who kicked him at Walter Hays Elementary School in October 2025.
Teacher Holly Harrison said Luo’s son is “working on his responses to peers when he is frustrated or upset,” according to the lawsuit filed on Monday.
Harrison wrote on the report card: ‘He is developing his ability to listen to others’ perspectives and collaborate with humility. We will keep working on this!’
Luo asked the district to change the report card on June 25, but the district denied her request.
The district’s decision was made after a hearing with no attorney present for Luo, which resulted in a 4-0 vote in closed session to deny Luo’s appeal.
Luo is suing the district for allegedly denying her a fair hearing and wants a judge to order the district to have another hearing and pay her attorney fees.
Superintendent Jason Glass said yesterday that student privacy laws prevent him from discussing any individual student’s records.
California law and board policy give families a defined process to challenge a grade or record, including a meeting with the superintendent’s designee, the opportunity to appeal to the board, and the right to add a written statement to the record.
The Incident at Recess
The incident that led to the report card comments occurred during a game of tag at recess in October 2025. According to the lawsuit, Luo’s son stuck his tongue out at another student who had kicked him.
- Luo’s son was playing with other students during recess when he got kicked by one of them.
- He responded by sticking his tongue out at the student who kicked him.
The Report Card Comments
Palo Alto Unified School District Accused of Unfair Hearing Practices
Luo alleges that the district denied her a fair hearing, which she believes was a crucial part of the process. She claims that the district's decision to remove her attorney from the virtual meeting and not provide her with adequate notice of the hearing time was unfair.
According to Luo, the district's actions were a clear attempt to intimidate and silence her. "I felt like I was being bullied by the district," she said in an interview. "They were trying to shut me down and prevent me from exercising my rights as a parent."
Luo is seeking a judge's order to require the district to hold another hearing, which would allow her attorney to be present and provide her with adequate notice of the time. She also wants the district to pay her attorney fees for the lawsuit.
The Implications of the Case
The case has significant implications for parents and students in the Palo Alto Unified School District. If Luo's lawsuit is successful, it could set a precedent for other parents who feel that their children have been unfairly treated by the district.
It also raises questions about the role of teachers and administrators in evaluating student behavior. While Harrison's comments on the report card were intended to be supportive and encouraging, they also reflect a broader cultural shift towards emphasizing social-emotional learning and character development in schools.
The case has sparked debate among parents and educators about the balance between supporting students' emotional needs and holding them accountable for their actions. Some argue that the district's emphasis on social-emotional learning is necessary to prepare students for success in an increasingly complex world, while others believe that it can be overly punitive and stifle creativity.
Marjorie Ouyang Criticizes Districts Handling of Luo Hearing
Luo's attorney, Marjorie Ouyang, has been a vocal advocate for her client throughout the process. Ouyang has stated that she believes the district's actions were "unfair and unjust" and that Luo was denied a fair hearing.
Assistant Superintendent Yolanda Conaway has come under scrutiny for removing Ouyang from the virtual meeting and not providing adequate notice of the hearing time. Conaway has maintained that her actions were within her authority as an administrator, but some have questioned whether she overstepped her bounds.
The Next Steps
Luo's lawsuit is currently pending in court, with a judge set to hear arguments on the district’s alleged denial of a fair hearing. If Luo is successful, it could lead to a new hearing and potentially even changes to the district’s policies and procedures for handling parent appeals.
For now, the case remains a contentious issue within the Palo Alto Unified School District community. Some parents have expressed support for Luo and her efforts to advocate for her son, while others have defended the district's actions as necessary to maintain order and discipline in the schools.
The outcome of the lawsuit will likely have significant implications for parents and students in the district, and could potentially set a precedent for other cases involving parent appeals and student behavior.
By The Numbers
| What | Number |
|---|---|
| Date of incident at recess | October 2025 |
| Date Luo asked district to change report card | June 25, 2026 |
| Date hearing with no attorney present for Luo | August 18, 2026 |
| Vote of board to deny Luo’s appeal | 4-0 |
Teacher Holly Harrison wrote on the report card that Luo’s son is “working on his responses to peers when he is frustrated or upset.” She also noted that he is developing his ability to listen to others’ perspectives and collaborate with humility.







